Saturday, May 10, 2014

Columbia Generating Station: Crud and Failed Fuel






50.59 Ultrasonic Fuel Cleaning Callaway Cycle 10 & 11



ML013540400
CFR 50.59 SUMMARY REPORT FOR CALLAWAY PLANT
14-Nov-01
RFR 19637
Approve the use of an ultrasonic fuel cleaner.
This RFR approved the use of an ultrasonic fuel cleaning apparatus to remove crud from partially burned fuel assemblies to be reloaded into the reactor and the immersion of the treated coupon assembly while fuel cleaning operations are being performed.
The ultrasonic cleaning process was developed by Dominion Engineering, Inc., under the sponsorship of EPRIs Robust Fuels Program. This evaluation concluded that use of the ultrasonic fuel cleaning apparatus in the spent fuel pool as described in this RFR would not adversely affect any safety related systems or components. Also it was determined that the use of the ultrasonic cleaning process on the fuel assemblies would not adversely affect the fuel assemblies such that they could not be operated for the remainder of Cycle 11. It was determined that no unreviewed safety question exists for this change.
ML003711866
CFR 50.59 SUMMARY REPORT FOR CALLAWAY PLANT
01-May-00
RFR 19637
Approve the use of an ultrasonic fuel cleaner.
Revision A to this RFR evaluated the use of an ultrasonic fuel cleaning apparatus to remove crud from up to 4 fuel assemblies with the intent of operating these fuel assemblies in the core for the remainder of Cycle 10.
Revision B to this RFR approved the use of the ultrasonic fuel cleaning apparatus to remove crud from up to 16 fuel assemblies to be loaded in the reactor core for Cycle 11.
The ultrasonic cleaning process was developed by Dominion Engineering, Inc., under the sponsorship of EPRIs Robust Fuels Program. This evaluation concluded that use of the ultrasonic fuel cleaning apparatus in the spent fuel pool as described in this RFR would not adversely affect any safety related systems or components. Also it was determined that the use of the ultrasonic cleaning process on the fuel assemblies would not adversely affect the fuel assemblies such that they could not be operated for the remainder of Cycle 10. It was determined that no unreviewed safety question exists for this change.

Ref: ETP-ZZ-ST022, Revision 000, Revision 001, and Revision 002
        ETP-ZZ-ST023, Revision 000 and Revision 001
       ETP-ZZ-ST024, Revision 000 and Revision 001
       ETP-ZZ-00050, Revision 000

Tuesday, May 6, 2014

50.59 at Callaway for Ultrasonic Fuel Cleaning

This may be the first 50.59 for Ultrasonic Fuel Cleaning among U. S. nuclear power plants, and this is only a summary that is gleaned from ML013540440.

CFR 50.59 SUMMARY REPORT FOR CALLAWAY PLANT
14-Nov-01
RFR 19637
Approve the use of an ultrasonic fuel cleaner.
This RFR approved the use of an ultrasonic fuel cleaning apparatus to remove crud from partially burned fuel assemblies to be reloaded into the reactor and the immersion of the treated coupon assembly while fuel cleaning operations are being performed.
The ultrasonic cleaning process was developed by Dominion Engineering, Inc., under the sponsorship of EPRIs Robust Fuels Program. This evaluation concluded that use of the ultrasonic fuel cleaning apparatus in the spent fuel pool as described in this RFR would not adversely affect any safety related systems or components. Also it was determined that the use of the ultrasonic cleaning process on the fuel assemblies would not adversely affect the fuel assemblies such that they could not be operated for the remainder of Cycle 11. It was determined that no unreviewed safety question exists for this change.

I've said it previously, Ultrasonic Fuel Cleaning is a complex process and it is amazing that a multitude of nuclear power plants have deployed this under 50.59.

Who knows?  Perhaps on-site reprocessing could proceed under 50.59. In that case, Ultrasonic Fuel Cleaning would be the initial complex process in a series of subsequent steps.

Sunday, May 4, 2014

Analysis: U. S. Patents, Ultrasonic Fuel Cleaning

          U. S. Patents, Ultrasonic Fuel Cleaning     
Number
Inventor
       Filed
       Issued
Owner
5,467,791
Kato
Feb-94
Nov-95
Toshiba
6,396,892
Frattini
Apr-00
May-02
EPRI
7,542,539
Frattini
Dec-01
Jun-09
EPRI
7,134,441
Gross
Jul-03
Nov-06
Dominion
8,165,261
Hussey
Jan-09
Apr-12
EPRI
8,372,206
Gross
Jan-09
Feb-13
Dominion
 

The above list of patents is revealing.  Toshiba filed its patent application more than six years prior to EPRI.  Although EPRI cites  Toshiba in its patent, EPRI has not acknowledged Toshiba's pioneering work in its publications.  (More later on this.)  

It is interesting that EPRI and Dominion are each separate owners among the above six patents.  In the case of EPRI 6,396,892 that was filed during April 2000, there are three inventors: Frattini, Varrin and Hunt.  Frattini worked for EPRI in Palo Alto, CA, while Varrin and Hunt  were employed by Dominion Engineering, Inc. of Reston, VA.  Very likely EPRI paid the bills while Dominion did the bulk, if not all of the inventing.

Of course, I do not have time to explore the shenanigans, but there are two  EPRI patents with Frattini as well as the same inventors from Dominion Engineering, Inc.  It is amazing.  The two Frattini-EPRI patents have the same title and summary, identical figures and brief descriptions,  but with different law firms, a different set of claims, different examiners, filing dates of April 2000 and December 2001, and corresponding issue dates  of May 2002 and June 2009.


Looking at the total picture of patents owned by EPRI and Dominion would take a lot of time and none of the parties are likely to disclose the games; but clearly there are shenanigans, and the expenses are likely mostly paid by EPRI (its supporting utilities and ultimately the by those who pay for juice).

The most recent patent is Dominion 8,372, 206 that issued during February 2013.  Dominion therein references deficiencies in the EPRI process as follows:
A number of ultrasonic cleaning systems have been developed for cleaning irradiated nuclear fuel assemblies including systems utilizing radial omni-directional ultrasonic cleaning technology as described, for example, in U.S. Pat. No. 6,396,892, the contents of which are incorporated herein by reference, in their entirety. FIG. 1 illustrates representative before and after photographs of fuel rods 100 in a fuel bundle cleaned using conventional radial omni-directional ultrasonic cleaning technology. Although, as reflected in FIG. 1, there is clear visual evidence of deposits being removed from the fuel assemblies, the cleaning is neither uniform nor complete, particularly with respect to the peripheral rods.

 Dominion further references deficiences of the EPRI omni-directional process as folows:

The inventors have determined that the tenacious layer currently associated with PWR fuel deposits has a threshold ultrasonic power density of approximately 200 watts/gallon (52.8 watts/liter) (as calculated using the methodology outlined below in Table 1). The invention consists of an ultrasonic cleaning device configured to achieve an ultrasonic power density on the order of 200 watts/gallon (52.8 watts/liter) or more. The invention utilizes arrays of planar transducers to achieve these high power densities rather than the conventional radial omni-directional transducers currently used for ultrasonic fuel cleaning.

As I said above, more later.

















































































Thursday, May 1, 2014

Crud in Nuclear Power Reactors and Ultrasonic Fuel Cleaning


Following is a copy of an entry to this blog on September 8, 2007.


Saturday, September 8, 2007

NRC Knows Little About Ultrasonic Fuel Cleaning



What is fantastic is that our NRC knows much more about the Paks event and the associated chemical cleaning equipment than it knows about ultrasonic fuel cleaning in the USA.
I sent the following e-mail to Chairman@nrc.gov and received an interesting reply from his Director, Division of Safety Systems, Nuclear Reactor Regulation.
PRM-50-84 and ultrasonic fuel cleaning and chemical cleaningAs an afterthought, it occurs to me that the NRC should have a complete record of experience with ultrasonic fuel cleaning at the nuclear power reactors that it licenses in the USA. Also, by now, the NRC should have a somewhat complete set of facts regarding chemical cleaning of power reactor fuel in Europe and elsewhere in the international scene; especially the experience with crud at Paks Unit 2 and the event with chemical cleaning on April 10, 2003.

So, I would like to hear from the NRC regarding these matters.































Actually, a search on the NRC's ADAMS system reveals quite a bit about the event of April 10, 2003, at Paks Unit 2. Much of this was revealed via several FOIAs. Of course there is a lot more to the event than has been disclosed by our NRC, and even they may not have the vital details. It would be interesting to see a TRACE analysis of that event, but it is unlikely that we will ever see one.


But what is fantastic is that our NRC knows much more about the Paks event and the associated chemical cleaning equipment than it knows about ultrasonic fuel cleaning in the USA. Although ultrasonic fuel cleaning is a complex physical-chemical process that is performed inside the containment buildings of several of our power reactors, the NRC has never performed a safety analysis of the equipment, and it has not reviewed any such safety analyses by its licensees.