Sunday, June 11, 2017

Thursday, June 1, 2017

This unidentified attack is an attack to be remembered.

Subject: This unidentified attack is an attack to be remembered.
Date:
6/1/2017 9:07:40 A.M. Mountain Daylight Time

In addition to tyranny, the following from our National Science Foundation is infuriating:
Review #3
https://www.fastlane.nsf.gov/researchadmin/images/spacer.gif
https://www.fastlane.nsf.gov/researchadmin/images/spacer.gif

Proposal Number:

1132890
NSF Program:

THERMAL TRANSPORT PROCESSES
Principal Investigator:

Leyse, Robert H
Proposal Title:

Proprietary Transformative Separations
Rating:

Fair

https://www.fastlane.nsf.gov/researchadmin/images/spacer.gif

REVIEW:
What is the intellectual merit of the proposed activity?

The most compelling portion of this proposal is that the PI has identified an anomalous boiling heat transfer regime from microscale wire surfaces. Unfortunately, the PI has not presented a convincing research plan that will lead to a fundamental understanding of the heat transfer process he has identified. Countless anomalous regimes have been identified in boiling heat transfer. While the PI believes that his discoveries are transformative, this Reviewer fails to see it. Truly transformative research will seek to explain the physical mechanisms driving the anomalous observations, and provide technologists with the understanding that may lead to technological advances. However, the PI fails to mention any of the various physical boiling phenomena at different length and time scale which may influence the process. For example, the PI claims his measurements are steady state. This completely ignores the time scales associated with ebullition. The PI claims the dispersive mechanism is turbulence without any evidence. It can just as easily be hypothesized that the dispersive mechanism is microbubble growth and collapse that has been observed in highly subcooled systems. It is unfortunate that the PI has expended so much effort to convince NSF to fund his proposed research. If the PI is convinced that his discoveries are transformative and can lead to revolutionary new technology, he should focus his efforts on developing that technology. For whatever it is worth, this Reviewer believes that the heat transfer behavior observed is confined to microscale wires, and attempts at scale-up would not be fruitful.

What are the broader impacts of the proposed activity?

It is difficult to identify broader impact associated with the proposal.

Summary Statement

Past Reviewers have been too gentle in pointing out the weaknesses of the proposed study. The PI should not be encouraged to resubmit a proposal covering the core topic.






Tuesday, May 16, 2017

Insiders and The Roots of Fukushima

Of course, there are countless roots, and it may be argued that some do not apply.  The number of applicable roots grows substantially if the ways of doing business are included.  Following is stuff from decades ago that documents NRC-EPRI relationships that are not otherwise disclosed.




This entry jumps ahead of a lot of documentation that I have and that I guess I'll have to place in book if I ever get around to writing that.  On November 7, 1984, EPRI (Rossin and Breen) told me my position was being eliminated, but that I'd have a few months to look for work elsewhere.  So, I looked elsewhere with no immediate success.  I talked to Jim Keppler of the NRC and showed him my memorandum, UHI Ultra High Risk, October 3, 1984, as part of several illustrations of my experience and capabilities.  Keppler asked if he could send this elsewhere in NRC and I agreed, however, I blanked out the source of the document as well as my name.

So, the following two pages are an interesting document that reveals very secret relationships between EPRI and the NRC that I was never aware of.  It also reveals turmoil.  I do not recall how I gained access to the following document; it most certainly was not sent to me.  I am inclined to doubt that Rossin was aware of it, but I do not know that.  I suspect that Layman and Lang were not aware that my position had been eliminated.  

Click on a page to enlarge and the back arrow to return.





I'm certainly pleased that EPRI (Layman and Lang) documented the above. This is a clear report of a basically secret set of arrangements between EPRI and the NRC and I suspect that those have continued in various forms over the years and are really intense in today's post-Fukushima world. 

The second page is "interesting" as it describes the "running around" in generating a response to Keppler.  The very last paragraph is also revealing as EPRI apologizes to the NRC for my contact with Keppler.  

Friday, February 10, 2017

Isotope Separation, Boron



This summary paragraph, Proximity Separation and Deposition in the Microscale, outlines Leyse’s transformative approach to isotope separation.  Leyse’s discoveries are now applied in the new field named Microscale Process Intensification.  With one set of apparatus, and with one platinum microscale heat transfer element, Leyse’s research covered the pressure range from 2 to 45 MPa, the heat flux range from very low to 4000 W/cm2 and the temperature range of the heat transfer element from 25 oC to 870 oC while bulk water temperature was maintained in the range of 20 oC. At the very high heat flux there is intense turbulence in the vicinity of the microscale heat transfer element. The local fluid temperatures range from the saturation temperature to intermediate temperatures.  The complex thermal hydraulics defies analysis with current tools.  A dilute solution of boric acid will decompose within the high temperature field to yield particles of insoluble boric oxide. A fraction of the particles of boron oxide thus produced will deposit on the hot element. If there is difference in the deposition rates, the mix of 10B and 11B on the element will be different than nature’s blend..  

Thursday, February 9, 2017

Nukiyama in microscale; text, but no slides, too bad.



This transformative presentation takes 10 minutes -- or less.  It was ahead of its time over 20 years ago and it still is.

This paper is Nukiyama in microscale over the pressure range from 200 to 6000 PSI.  Nukiyama used a platinum wire simultaneously as a heat transfer element and a resistance thermometer. 

Here is my Nukiyama element: diameter 7.5 microns, length 1.15 millimeters.

It is installed in the lower end of an upright tube that is filled with pressurized water, pure and degasified at about 20 Centigrade.  The steel tube is used for these pool boiling runs at higher pressures.

The benchtop apparatus has the pool boiling tube, the pressurizing pump, the junction box and programmed power supply, a PC with Excel for data logging, and in the back, a Rosemount recording pressure transducer.

A run takes about 11 seconds and data is recorded every tenth of a second.  Heat flux is smoothly increased and then decreased.  In this run at 1000 PSI with the water at about 20 Centigrade, the peak was over 4000 Watts per square centimeter.  The average power is about one half watt, so the energy is about 6 watt-seconds, or less than two calories for the 11 second run.  So, the temperature of a local gram of water increases by less than two Centigrade.
Following is the reduced data for the 1000 PSI run.  It doesn’t get any better than this although it gets more exciting.  The transition to phase change, I call it the Nukiyama point, is at about 2100 watts per square centimeter.  This transition is extremely sharp, there is no sluggishness.  That is also the case at the turnaround at 4100.  I want to increase the recording rate to every millisecond in further runs.  Note that the return is on the same path as the rise.  Clearly, the local temperature stays very close to 20 Centigrade, otherwise the return would not overlay. 


Here are several runs, three subcritical, one transcritical, and four supercritical. You have seen the dissection of the 1000 psi run; the 200 and 2500 of this plot are similar.  The dotted line is the transcritical run at 3000.  The four supercritical runs range from 3600 to 6000.

Here are the 3600 and 6000 runs.  The 6000 has a narrower spread between the power up and the power down.

The 3,000 transcritical run is superimposed on the runs you have just seen.  I want to expand this territory with runs having millisecond data collection.

The supercritical runs are all well-behaved in this plot.  Even the transcritical falls in its proper place.

The point of the following plot of the subcritical runs is that at 200 psi the Nukiyama point is 65 Centigrade beyond saturation while at 2500 and above, that delta T is very narrow.




With the permission of Professor Victor Yagov of Moscow, following is his recent analysis. At 200 psi he reports substantial Delta T’s, at 3000, the Delta T’s are vanishing.  Multiply Yagov’s values by 100 to get to my units.

This is the transcritical run.  Again, I want millisecond data recording next time in the search for the aspects of the jump.  Note that saturation temperature is very close to critical.

Here is limited data.  With a somewhat larger microscale element the heat fluxes at the Nukiyama points are reduced, however the temperature of the points is unchanged.  The transcritical characteristic is the same even though the pressure is 100 psi less; the saturation temperature is still very near critical.

I think this is sensational.  The procedure is to pressurize the apparatus to about 6000 psi, apply a substantial heat flux in one step, and maintain that heat flux as pressure is smoothly reduced over about 20 seconds, turn off power at about 200 psi.  Note the gradual increase in temperature as pressure is reduced, then the upward jump of over 200 Centigrade at around 3700 psi, followed by a smooth increase of another 100 Centigrade to the critical pressure, then a smooth decrease of nearly 200 Centigrade, then a downward jump of about 150 centigrade to the critical temperature. At that point the subcritical boiling begins and continues until the power is turned off. At the lowest heat flux there is a smooth continuous plot over the entire pressure range with no intervening steps. The four plots at increasing heat fluxes are neatly nested.



Here are the data points.  I captured one point during the upward jump in two runs. Of course, runs are needed with millisecond recording, etc.
Here are the plots of subcritical phase change only.  The plots are very close; however the heat fluxes are distinct.  As was measured in the constant pressure runs at subcritical pressures and also calculated by Professor Yagov, the delta T from phase change to saturation increases as the pressure is reduced.


 This shows the impact of nitrogen saturation at 1000 psi.  I never reduced these plots to heat flux and temperature; I did not need to in order to get the patent. Nitrogen reduces the heat transfer coefficient during natural circulation; however phase change heat transfer begins at a somewhat lower temperature and heat flux.  I filed this patent during 1995 and it issued during 1997, the year that Berkeley started its microscale journal. 

Thursday, November 24, 2016

INL CAB October 27, 2016


The Idaho National Laboratory (INL) Site Environmental Management (EM) Citizens Advisory Board (CAB) held its quarterly meeting on Wednesday, February 17, 2016, at the Hilton Garden Inn in Idaho Falls, Idaho. An audio recording of the meeting was created and may be reviewed by calling CAB Support Staff at 208-557-7886.


Public Comment 

Robert Leyse, Sun Valley, commented that in the June 2016 meeting minutes McBride asked if DOE regrets having waited to begin pilot testing at Hazen Laboratories until the Inspector General suggested it. Leyse noted that he addressed the CAB a year ago, and provided a series of links that are available in the October 2015 meeting minutes.

Those links show the following: In a report dated September 11, 2006, a review commissioned by DOE-ID and chaired by David S. Cosin, PhD, reported several findings including Finding One of their report: “Documentation, data reduction and analysis are incomplete for the pilot scale testing carried out to date at Hazen Laboratories. Consequently, thorough analysis of these data has not been completed; insufficient attention to these aspects of pilot testing has been the cause of other DOE program failures.” Leyse commented that IWTU can be added to those failures. Ten years ago, Hazen reporting was deficient. Leyse asked why DOE is resuming work at Hazen today. The third link reveals that on January 24, 2007, the Defense Nuclear Facility Safety Board (DNFSB) had no objections to proceeding with construction of IWTU. The first link shows that during 2014, DNFSB did not authorize operation of IWTU with radioactive feed, “A lack of assurance that the facility can safely proceed with nuclear operations…” Leyse commented that it is surprising that DNFSB did not approve nuclear operations as they should never have approved construction of the facility to begin with. 

Following is the Leyse list of references that Leyse provided at the CAB meeting in Sun valley, Idaho, on October 29, 015

The Idaho National Laboratory (INL) Site Environmental Management (EM) Citizens Advisory Board (CAB) held its quarterly meeting on Thursday, October 29, 2015, at the Sun Valley Inn in Sun Valley, Idaho. An audio recording of the meeting was created and may be reviewed by calling CAB Support Staff at 208-557-0843

Letter provided by Mr. Robert Leyse during the Public Comment Period:

LEYSE STATEMENT DISCLOSING DNFSB EVALUATIONS OF IWTU 
Hello, I am Robert Leyse of Sun Valley, Idaho and I want the public to know that I have found the following via GOOGLE. I am including the links so that others may check my findings. 

Link 1: 
http://www.dnfsb.gov/sites/default/files/Board%20Activities/Reports/Staff%20Issue%20Reports/I daho%20National%20Laboratory/2014/sir_2014523_24466_37.pdf 

DNFSB investigated the status of the IWTU and reported its findings to DOE May 23, 2014. It reported “…a lack of assurance that the facility can safely proceed with nuclear operations.” “Therefore, pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 2286b(d), the Board requests a report and briefing within 30 days, on DOE's evaluation of the need for additional independent assessment at the completion of IWTU startup testing and prior to the introduction of radioactive waste feed.”

Link 2: 
http://www.dnfsb.gov/sites/default/files/Board%20Activities/Letters/2014/ltr_2014620_24626.pdf 

This is the 30 day reply letter from DOE to DNFSB and it reports agreement that “…IWTU will benefit from an additional independent assessment…” 

Link 3: 
http://thortt.azurewebsites.net/docs/DNFSB%20Letter.pdf 

This documents a DNSFB review, January 24, 2007. “The Board has no significant safety issues with the project at this time (Critical Decision 2/3B). The final design, however, is progressing and there remain a number of items the Board believes must be addressed before the approval of final design and construction of the project.” … “The Board commends DOE for considering a potential future mission in this facility. Further, DOE convened an expert panel early in preliminary design to confirm that the design of the facility could accommodate this mission. The Board is encouraged by the project’s commitment to address this panel’s recommendations.” 

Link 4: 
http://www.cresp.org/crespII/CRESPII_Report/E_attachment/INLreview_complete_9_11_06.pdf 

This is the report of the expert panel that is praised in 4. The report lists 17 findings and associated recommendations. Here is the first of 17: “Finding 1. Documentation, data reduction and analysis are incomplete for the pilot-scale studies carried out to date at Hazen Laboratories. … Insufficient attention to these aspects of pilot-testing has been a cause of other DOE program failures.” ”Recommendation 1. Thorough documentation, data reduction and analysis of the results from pilot scale testing carried out to date should be completed as soon as possible and to the extent practical before initiating the planned next stage of pilot-scale testing.” LEYSE 

CLOSING STATEMENT Others may download the above links and also search for other links regarding the IWTU. You may easilyaccess the above links via GOOGLE at leyse nuclear power blog dnfsb.